*A North Carolina judge ruled in favor of Fantasia’s former lover Antwaun Cook in his divorce proceedings against his ex-wife Paula, saying the pair separated on Sept. 14, 2009, and not in June 2010, as Paula’s claimed.

In effect, this means Cook was indeed already separated from Paula during his affair with Fantasia.

Paula had claimed that she and Antwuan were still together and happily married when Fantasia entered the picture.

It is unknown whether Paula will continue to pursue a lawsuit against Fantasia under North Carolina’s unique Alienation of Affection law.